Image default

The Reality About Homework

“Most homework academics set is crap.” Dylan Wiliam, ResearchEd 2014.

The topic of homework conjures up robust opinions. Academics, dad and mom and college students themselves all have a view on the matter and people views are sometimes diametrically opposed. Dylan Wiliam, again in 2014, shared a really robust opinion that didn’t precisely condemn the proof and motion associated to homework to the dustbin, however he poked a gaping gap into our each assumption about homework and its influence.

At Huntington Faculty, we battled with the problems and surveyed one of the best accessible proof, from the EEF Toolkit (Secondary and Major – notice the essential variations right here: homework is rather more efficient with older kids), to particular current research on homework (this one by way of Dan Willingham). The IEEGreatest Proof in Temporary‘ e-newsletter has finished an excellent job of collating homework analysis HERE. Actually, realizing the proof base might help our decision-making, although it’s after all somewhat extra sophisticated than that.


Homework (or residence studying, or “prolonged studying” as we relabelled it at Huntington) is seemingly simplest when it includes follow or rehearsal of subject material already taught. College students mustn’t sometimes be uncovered to new materials for his or her residence studying, until they’re judged extra knowledgeable learners. Complicated, open ended homework is commonly accomplished least successfully; whereas, brief, frequent homework, carefully monitored by academics is extra prone to have extra influence. This might embody summarising notes; utilizing graphic organisers to recast classroom supplies; guided analysis; examination query practise; guided revision and so on.

House studying is confirmed to be simpler with older college students than their youthful counterparts. That is sometimes as a result of they’re extra in a position to self-regulate their studying and so they have extra background information to attract upon. For comparable causes, excessive means college students sometimes profit extra from residence studying than low means college students.

Trainer scaffolding is crucial to information efficient residence studying. Parental involvement is fascinating, but it surely shouldn’t be important, in any other case the character of the duty is probably going too complicated for profitable completion.



Cathy Vatterott (2010) recognized 5 basic traits of excellent homework: function, effectivity, possession, competence, and aesthetic enchantment.

  1. Goal: all homework assignments are imply­ingful & college students should additionally perceive the aim of the project and why it is vital within the context of their tutorial expertise (Xu, 2011).
  2. Effectivity: homework mustn’t take an inordinate period of time and may require some laborious considering.
  3. Possession: college students who really feel related to the content material and project be taught extra and are extra motivat­ed. Offering college students with alternative of their assignments is one technique to create possession.
  4. Competence: college students ought to really feel competent in finishing homework. With a purpose to obtain this, it’s benefi­cial to desert the one-size-fits-all mannequin. Homework that college students can’t do with out assist just isn’t good homework.
  5. Inspiring: A well-considered & clearly designed useful resource and job impacts positively upon scholar motivation.


We must always pose ourselves some tough questions:

  • Has the aim of the homework been made clear to college students?
  • Are the scholars in possession of all of the assets required to undertake the duty independently?
  • What are the prevailing beliefs about residence studying (college students & academics) that we have to recognise/problem?
  • How can we finest leverage parental assist for residence studying that’s successfully communicated?
  • How do you intend to offer particular and well timed suggestions to college students on their residence studying?


Possibly Wiliam is true and that whatever the proof, an excessive amount of of the homework we set is simply crap! The problem is actually a wholesome one given the fee when it comes to time for all concerned. We must always anticipate that each instructor and college chief understands the nuanced proof that attends homework, with the variations that relate to people, teams and college students of very completely different ages and phases of improvement. We are going to nonetheless be left with tough choices and no little disagreement, however we can be higher off having tackled the difficulty correctly.

If you wish to learn extra in regards to the proof that attends homework, then attempt the next:

  • Professor Sue Hallam, from the Institute of Training, has written a superb abstract of homework, entitled ‘Homework: Its Makes use of and Abuses‘.
  • The Time journal article is a useful and accessible abstract of the controversy, entitled: ‘Homework: Is It Any Good for Youngsters‘.
  • This ASCD instructional management article just isn’t the newest not too long ago, however it is vitally good and clear: ‘If Solely They’d Do Their Work’.


The weblog first appeared on the Huntington Analysis Faculty weblog – have a look HERE and join the e-newsletter from our nice group of teacher-writers HERE.