Image default

Why Entire-College Literacy Fails!

There isn’t a extra necessary act in training than serving to youngsters to be taught to learn. I’m positive we will agree that growing our college students as assured readers, writers and audio system is the core enterprise of each trainer, no matter age, section or topic specialism. Too typically although we take this important work, bundle it up with the label of ‘literacy’,’ then we anticipate a singular college chief to work miracles.

The function of the ‘Literacy Coordinator’ is a modern-day Sisyphus. Like an annual ceremony, we set literacy targets, compose complicated plans, rattle out audits and stack up knowledge in spreadsheets, anticipating the Coordinator to push the whole-school literacy boulder up the  mountain. The matter of ‘literacy’ actually is a boulder of gargantuan proportions, past the desire and wit of any particular person chief.

Is it time to confess that we have now as many failures than we have now successes in terms of whole-school literacy? In so doing, we could supply hope to the put upon Literacy Coordinator, crushed because the too typically are by the monumental weight on their shoulders.

Geoff Barton, in his sage e book, ‘Don’t Name it Literacy!‘, made a necessary level. By labeling up the tutorial language of faculty and the technique of speaking our curriculum as ‘literacy’, we wrongly supply it up as one thing extraneous, to be carried out within the nook of coaching days and to begrudgingly audit through the flagging ultimate weeks of the summer time. As a substitute, we must always see studying, writing, vocabulary, talking, listening, debate, and extra, because the complicated tapestry of nice instructing, enacted in each lesson, in each section and topic area, by each trainer.

One key motive why whole-school literacy fails is that the assemble of ‘literacy’ is just far too huge, complicated and unwieldy. Think about for a second simply a few of the points that may match beneath the broad umbrella of ‘literacy’:

  • Studying for pleasure;
  • Studying points (similar to poor decoding, weak comprehension, dyslexia, and the readability and accessibility of texts for our college students);
  • Educational vocabulary;
  • Instructor explanations, speak and questioning;
  • Enhancing writing;
  • Enhancing spelling and writing accuracy;
  • Talking and listening;
  • Enhancing trainer information and offering coaching for the entire above;
  • Growing dad and mom’ information and understanding of the entire above.

There you go, Literacy Coordinator…repair that. Sisyphus is reborn!

After all, in attempting to repair so many issues, we truly deal with little or no with significant affect. Take one of many points above. I’ll go along with tutorial vocabulary, because it is likely one of the underlying elements figuring out the larger, more durable curriculum that’s at the moment a urgent want at school.

And not using a correct analysis of scholars’ studying talents and vocabulary information, in addition to trainer confidence and competence on this regard, we could discover ‘solutions’ to questions we that weren’t important within the first place. We have to dig into the out there exterior proof too, higher understanding studying (probably the most superior cognitive achievements of our species no much less),  earlier than sharing that information and making sense of it. We have to pilot, enact, assess and analysis our work on vocabulary.

All of this work, simply on one mere strand of ‘literacy’, takes quite a lot of time, instruments and coaching.

One more reason for the failure of whole-school literacy is that we lack the required experience on any given literacy matter, similar to vocabulary. One widespread failing is that we do deal with the very best out there proof in generic phrases, however we fail to handle what meaning for topic domains (in secondary and first phases). It might be that instructing college students an understanding of phrase elements (morphology) could be very helpful as vocabulary instruction in Science, however the identical technique could not show as helpful in Historical past. Time to inquire about our approaches in every topic self-discipline is required.

We come to our failings in evaluation that account for failings in our whole-school literacy method. The area of literacy is so huge, so complicated, that it may well show onerous to search out useable assessments. As soon as extra, we have now to shrink the issue of literacy all the way down to one thing extra manageable – a spotlight like vocabulary information – that may be reliably assessed, with some validity, to evaluate whether or not our approaches have been working or not.

In narrowing our focus, we will discover good assessments of the strand of literacy we want to enhance, thereby making the act of addressing whole-school literacy, nicely…much less Sisyphean.

While you account for the size and significance of every strand of literacy, the notion that any particular person can ‘coordinate’ all of it, notably given the topic particular nature of a lot of what we time period ‘literacy’, begins to seem like fairly unrealistic. To handle any facet of faculty enchancment requires a deep, systematic method to the work, with each trainer, center and senior chief proving  a significant a part of the coordination. In attempting to handle an excessive amount of in our college enchancment efforts, we fail to guage what truly accounts for any discernible enhancements.

We have to begin our try to grapple with literacy by accessing the huge bulk of obtainable proof on it to assist us determine the wants of our college students. The current publication by the Schooling Endowment Basis – the KS2 Literacy Steering Report (discover it HERE) – provides a useable synthesis for colleges to provoke their exploration into the extra particular points confronted by our college students:

As soon as we id our problem, with good trainer judgements and deploying assessments with validity, we will go away the time period ‘literacy’ behind and start to enhance vocabulary information in English, or writing in Historical past, or explanations in Science, and so forth. In impact, we deliver our collective weight to bear and crack the boulder in our college. We every heave our rock up the mountain and elevate a substantial weight off our Literacy Coordinator’s shoulders!


If you wish to hear extra about this argument and the difficulty of literacy, at ResearchEd York 2017, on the eighth of July, at Huntington College in York, I’m going to speak about ‘Why Entire-College Literacy Fails!‘ in a lot higher depth. I hope to see you there – you possibly can seize your ticket HERE.


Weblog title picture: ‘Sisyphus’ by Titian